individual honors

NAIA All-America 

 Sarah Kaufman                                                    2005       Honorable Mention

NAIA All-America Scholar-Athletes

 Erin Abbey                                                             2001, 2002  
 Robyn Althoff 2005, 2006
 Elizabeth Ballard                                    2002
 Joy Bamford 2004, 2005
 Kristyn Bollig 2003
 Shelly Bradbury 2010, 2011
 Randee Bushnell 2011
 Brittany Carlson 2009, 2010
 Leah Cressman 2008, 2009
Kaitlyn Dreman 2013
 Kara Fultz 2004, 2005
 Ashley Gonterman 2005, 2006
 Michelle Hawthorne 2011
 Amber Hirschy 2002, 2003
 Hannah Kaufman 2005, 2006
 Alyssa Krause 2012, 2013
 Jessica Krause 2012, 2013
 Rachel Mathews 2011
 Bethany McGraw 2008, 2009
 Kara Shoemaker 2001
 Christi Shook 2004, 2005
Amy Snider 2013
 Rachel Warrick 2006
 Heidi Zeman 2011

NAIA All-Region

 Erin Abbey                                                             2002         Second Team       
 Robyn Althoff 2003 Second Team
 Elizabeth Ballard   2002 Second Team
 Sarah Kaufman 2005 First Team

MCC/Crossroads All-Conference

 Erin Abbey                                                             2002
 Courtney Baker 2012
 Erin Barclay 2011
 Sam Cubic 2010, 2013
 Kara Fultz 2003
 Brittany Hartman 2010
 Sara Holtsberry                                   1998
 Justine Jost 2009
 Hannah Kaufman 2004, 2005
 Sarah Kaufman 2004, 2005, 2007  
Jessica Krause 2013
 Bethany McGraw 2007, 2008
 Heather O'Keefe 2004
 Kara Shoemaker 2001
 Christi Shook 2002
 Stephanie Spitnale   2008
 Lisa Underwood 2012

Ryan Burgher, Coach of the Year 2010  

Tom Datema, Coach of the Year 2002